To Santa or not to Santa
I don’t think I realized how strong feelings about Santa ran until recently. Lisa Belkin on Motherlode is posting 4 essays from parents for and against Santa. Even though only two of the essay have been posted, the comments have been very interesting to read. I have had people tell me how and when they revealed the Santa secret to their kids, but I just never understood that it was a strongly guarded secret. Deep down, I suspected the kid already knew and were humoring their parents – the way you would pretend surprise at a surprise party you knew about. But I must have been wrong. Some Many parents apparently go to great lengths to create the Illusion of Santa. I think that is ridiculous.
Equally ridiculous is the fact that some parents are also going to great lengths to break the illusion. And I find it amusing that the same parents do not take any issue with celebrating the birth of Jesus on December 25.
Just do what I do – let the children be and enjoy the show.
Perhaps my lack of emotion for or against Santa is due to my growing up without Santa. I grew up instead with Father Christmas. He looks just like Santa and he hands out Christmas gifts. But he does not climb down chimneys (we don’t have chimneys in Nigeria). In fact, he does not visit homes. He may visit schools or other locations with high concentrations of kids but is most likely to be found at the TV station where kids stream in to sit on his lap and collect a gift pack.
Nobody said Father Christmas was real. And nobody said he wasn’t. Kids knew that “somebody’s daddy” was dressed up in the red suit and when Father Christmas appeared at school, rumors would spread about who’s daddy it might be. But that did not spoil the magic for Father Christmas, regardless of who was in the suit, always gave out gifts (even if they were cheap and not things you wanted).
So what do my kids believe?
My 7 year old daughter believes in Santa. I have not influenced her belief in either direction. She also believes in the tooth fairy. And that, I have influenced by replacing teeth from under her pillow with money. Why? Because I think it is fun. And I have enjoyed listening to her questions and rationalizations of how the tooth fairy gets into the house. Similarly, Santa has been undergoing some scrutiny but so far, he is holding up. If she ever asks me if Santa is real, I will tell her the truth. But she hasn’t asked me. She has told me that someone from school said so but she told him that she believes in Santa. She has wondered why Santa rode a firetruck to our house last year (we participated in a neighborhood Santa delivery) instead of his sleigh. She’s wondered how many cookies he can really eat in one night and whether it was healthy. She’s wondered how he gets around the continents and suggested that each continent probably has a different Santa. She’s wondered how he makes it to all houses in just one night. She’s complained about the less than white coloration of one Santa’s beard.
I hope she’s close to declaring that the whole thing is a fraud but I’m not going to rush her. At this point, she believes there are some Santa impersonators but she still believes.
I think this is an innocuous opportunity to allow her to use her own logical thinking to come to the truth. To learn that things are not always what they seem. And the fact that millions of people saying something exists does not mean that it does. But for this to be effective, I believe she needs to reach the conclusion by herself rather than me telling her what she should believe.
